Fixing Free Shipping Banner vs. Shipping Policy Mismatches on Shopify (GMC Pre-Review)
Direct Answer Summary
One of the easiest ways to fail a Google Merchant Center (GMC) Misrepresentation review on Shopify is leaving an outdated free-shipping threshold in your /policies/shipping-policy page (e.g., "Free shipping over $69") after updating your homepage announcement bar to "Free US Shipping $50+". Use the read-only StorePolicyCheck scanner below to extract verbatim side-by-side quotes in under 60 seconds (free preview includes up to 2 verified conflicts; $29 one-time pass unlocks 5 post-edit verification re-scans over 14 days).
No signup or OAuth required. Public pages only; does not guarantee GMC reinstatement. Zero-charge if 0 hard issues found.
Anonymized Case: Post-Promo Banner Left Out of Sync with Policy Page
“Free Standard Contiguous US Shipping on Orders $50+”
“Orders of $75 or more qualify for free standard ground shipping within the continental US.”
Why this fails review: Shoppers and Google reviewers see conflicting shipping promises for baskets between $50.00 and $74.99 under identical US standard shipping conditions.
Applicable Scope & When NOT to Worry
- Different thresholds for Contiguous US ($50+) vs. Alaska/Hawaii/Canada ($99+) are completely valid as long as geographic qualifiers are stated clearly on both pages.
- "Calculated at checkout" in a weight-based Shopify store is not a missing-policy error, provided your GMC shipping table never underquotes actual checkout rates.
Official Google Merchant Center References
Frequently Asked Questions
Does StorePolicyCheck require connecting Shopify Admin or GMC OAuth?
No. StorePolicyCheck performs 100% read-only HTTP checks on your public US/USD storefront pages plus up to 3 optional reference numbers you type in manually—zero backend access or account-linking risk.