StorePolicyCheckShopify US/USD
All GMC Pre-Review Guides
Rule R05Shopify US / USD· 2026-11-19

Aligning Return Shipping Responsibility & Restocking Fees on Shopify for GMC

Direct Answer Summary

A frequent policy trap on Shopify is advertising "Free 30-Day Returns" in a headline while stating in a lower paragraph that "customers are responsible for return shipping labels" without clarifying defective vs. remorse returns. Google requires unambiguous disclosure of who pays return postage for standard change-of-mind returns, plus explicit disclosure of any restocking fee in both your written policy and GMC Return Settings.

Live Read-Only Shopify US/USD Verifier · Free Preview ($29 Pass Optional)

No signup or OAuth required. Public pages only; does not guarantee GMC reinstatement. Zero-charge if 0 hard issues found.

Anonymized Case: Unqualified "Free Returns" Headline vs. Paid Return Label Clause

/policies/refund-policy Heading
“Hassle-Free & Free Returns Within 30 Days”
/policies/refund-policy Fine Print
“A $8.95 return shipping fee will be deducted from your refund total.”

Why this fails review: Directly contradicts the "Free Returns" promise for standard orders.

Verified Alignment Fix: Clarified both clauses: "Free return shipping on defective or incorrect items. Standard returns within 30 days incur an $8.95 prepaid return label deduction (0% restocking fee)."

Applicable Scope & When NOT to Worry

  • Free return shipping paired with a clearly disclosed restocking fee (e.g., 10% on opened electronics) is two distinct fee types—not a contradiction—just verify the restocking fee is entered in GMC.

Official Google Merchant Center References

Frequently Asked Questions

Does StorePolicyCheck auto-generate generic legal policies?

Never blindly. Generic copy-pasted policies that do not match how you actually ship and process returns create new misrepresentation violations. StorePolicyCheck shows exact conflicting quotes first, asks you to confirm your real rule, and provides targeted single-clause wording.