How we verify findings and measure rule precision
We never invent a 0–100 compliance score. Every finding requires a verbatim quote verified against your fetched page HTML, and rules with fewer than 20 verified live samples display "Measuring" rather than estimated numbers.
1. Six finding states
Two public surfaces on your store make contradictory statements under the same market and condition (backed by both quotes).
A core policy link returns HTTP 404 or omits a required disclosure (such as return window or contact channel).
Worth checking against your actual business operations or Merchant Center settings; always shown free and never locked.
Both compared surfaces were readable and matched.
Page was behind a bot challenge, password, dynamic portal, or cross-currency view — never guessed as a conflict.
Awarded on re-check only when both previously conflicting pages are re-read live and now match.
2. Complete rule catalog & empirical precision ledger
Experimental rules (R16, R19, R20, R21) are mechanically capped at "Please confirm" until >=20 live external samples confirm >=95% precision.
| Code | What we check | Stage | Live precision | Sample n | Updated |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| R01 | Shipping policy availability & delivery timeframes Official reference | GA | Measuring | Measuring (<20) | 2026-11-22 |
| R02 | Return & refund policy availability & clarity Official reference | GA | Measuring | Measuring (<20) | 2026-11-22 |
| R03 | Free-shipping threshold banner vs. shipping policy Official reference | GA | Measuring | Measuring (<20) | 2026-11-22 |
| R04 | Return window days across policy, FAQ, and product tabs Official reference | GA | Measuring | Measuring (<20) | 2026-11-22 |
| R05 | Who pays return shipping & restocking fees Official reference | GA | Measuring | Measuring (<20) | 2026-11-22 |
| R06 | Visible product/variant price vs. structured data Google reads Official reference | GA | Measuring | Measuring (<20) | 2026-11-22 |
| R07 | Unrecognized external or leftover template emails in policy text Official reference | GA | Measuring | Measuring (<20) | 2026-11-22 |
| R08 | Customer contact channel availability & valid mailto links Official reference | GA | Measuring | Measuring (<20) | 2026-11-22 |
| R09 | Unfilled theme placeholder text (Lorem ipsum / bracket tokens) Official reference | GA | Measuring | Measuring (<20) | 2026-11-22 |
| R10 | Broken footer navigation links & empty social media icons Official reference | GA | Measuring | Measuring (<20) | 2026-11-22 |
| R11 | Storefront robots.txt blocking Googlebot or Storebot-Google Official reference | GA | Measuring | Measuring (<20) | 2026-11-22 |
| R12 | Cross-border entity registration vs. warehouse origin disclosure Official reference | Beta | Measuring | Measuring (<20) | 2026-11-22 |
| R13 | Product images below 500×500 pixels (Jan 31, 2027 spec) Official reference | GA | Measuring | Measuring (<20) | 2026-11-22 |
| R14 | Subscription, bundle, or currency-switcher apps altering displayed price Official reference | Beta | Measuring | Measuring (<20) | 2026-11-22 |
| R15 | Unsubstantiated medical or cure claims in product copy Official reference | Beta | Measuring | Measuring (<20) | 2026-11-22 |
| R16 | Extra paid items automatically added to cart (e.g. shipping protection) Official reference | Experimental (capped) | Measuring | Measuring (<20) | 2026-11-22 |
| R17 | Resetting countdown timers, unlinked press logos, or supplier image hosts Official reference | Beta | Measuring | Measuring (<20) | 2026-11-22 |
| R18 | UK & EU mandatory 14-day statutory return minimum Official reference | Beta | Measuring | Measuring (<20) | 2026-11-22 |
| R19 | Street address consistency across pages & shared registered-agent suites Official reference | Experimental (capped) | Measuring | Measuring (<20) | 2026-11-22 |
| R20 | Support email mail-server reachability & free-webmail check Official reference | Experimental (capped) | Measuring | Measuring (<20) | 2026-11-22 |
| R21 | Domain registration age vs. "established since" claims on page Official reference | Experimental (capped) | Measuring | Measuring (<20) | 2026-11-22 |
| R22 | Promotional text in product titles, catalog-wide strikethroughs & 0g weights Official reference | Beta | Measuring | Measuring (<20) | 2026-11-22 |
3. How we test & calibrate rules
Golden test stores: Every code change runs against 12 purpose-built golden test stores (including 4 clean control stores) enforcing 0 false conflicts on clean stores and >=95% recall.
Heterogeneous dual-judge & human audit: Findings pass a mechanical verbatim quote gate, cross-family dual-judge verification, and merchant "This looks wrong" dispute reviews.
4. What public scans cannot see
- Private identity documents, incorporation reviews, and linked-account history inside Merchant Center
- Google Ads billing holds and payment profile verification
- Password-locked storefronts or final carrier tax calculations requiring shopper PII
5. Methodology changelog
2026-11-22 — Capped experimental rules R16, R19, R20, and R21 at "Please confirm" pending >=20 live samples; shipped 5,000-SKU paginated binary image header inspection.